An nameless reader quotes a report from Ars Technica: A Philadelphia man has been freed after a federal appeals courtroom dominated that his continued detention was violating federal legislation. Francis Rawls, a former police officer, had been in jail since 2015, when a federal decide held him in contempt for failing to decrypt two laborious drives taken from his dwelling. The federal government believes they comprise baby pornography.
After shedding that attraction, Rawls raised one other problem: the federal statute that permits judges to carry witnesses in contempt for refusing to testify, handed in 1970, states that “in no occasion shall such confinement exceed eighteen months.” The federal government argued that this provision did not apply to Rawls as a result of he was a suspect, not a witness. Additionally, the rule applies to a “continuing earlier than or ancillary to any courtroom or grand jury.” However as a result of the federal government hadn’t formally charged Rawls with against the law, the federal government argued, there was no courtroom continuing below manner. Final week, a three-judge panel of the third Circuit rejected this argument in a 2-1 vote. The courtroom’s two-judge majority held that Congress had meant for the 18-month limitation to use broadly to any authorized continuing, not only a formal trial. And whereas Rawls was a suspect within the case, he was additionally a witness. The sensible result’s that, not less than in federal courtroom, somebody can solely be imprisoned for 18 months for refusing to open an encrypted gadget. The federal government says it has different proof suggesting that Rawls possessed baby pornography, “so prosecutors could possibly piece collectively sufficient proof to convict him, even with out entry to his encrypted laborious drives,” the report provides. “One of many two judges who fashioned the third Circuit’s majority urged the trial courtroom decide to think about the 4 years of imprisonment Rawls has already served if he ultimately has to condemn Rawls after a baby pornography conviction.”
Learn extra of this story at Slashdot.